Is The Garmin Approach S1 GPS Golf Watch Too Basic To Be Worthwhile?
The Garmin Approach S1 GPS Golf Watch (Preloaded with US Courses) sounds like quite a simple device from its specification but there are plenty of features to appeal to new users that are interested in the potential of a golf watch.
In addition to the high-sensitivity GPS receiver for pre-loaded course information, this waterproof watch also has a monochrome LCD display, odometer and alarm. This watch seems to have all the basic, necessary functions required so how well does it perform on the course?
Some Noted Features of the Garmin Approach S1 Golf GPS Watch
- Preloaded with 14,000+ US and Canada courses
- 1.0 inch monochrome LCD display
- High-sensitivity GPS receiver
- Provides yardages to front, middle and back of the green
- Waterproof (IPX7) golf watch
- Battery life: three weeks in watch mode, eight hours in GPS mode
What benefits have golfers noted in their reviews for this Garmin Approach S1?
The range of courses available and the general design of the watch are among the great aspects being mentioned in positive user reviews. This system has more than 14,000 U.S. and Canadian courses available to view and it is worth noting that even though the product options state either US courses or Canada courses, it is free to download the other set if you plan to cross the boarder.
Many also appreciate the comfort provided by the design because it is quite light with a good strap – some say it is a bit large but it is not excessively so for a watch of this type – and others highlight the easy-to-read, sunlight-viewable screen and the additional odometer.
There are, however, slightly more mixed reviews regarding the accuracy of this Garmin S1 GPS Golf Watch because while there are many 5 stars reviews for the product that praise this aspect, there are other users that say it can be a problem.
The positive comments alone would suggest that there is absolutely nothing to worry about because of the precision of the distance finder and there are additional comments about the reliability of the auto-detect system that changes the hole displayed.
The problem is that some buyers have measured inaccuracies and pointed out that this reliability decreases slightly when the weather is overcast. It seems that this S1 is occasionally 5-10 yards off and while this may not be an issue for first timers, it can be a big problem for those advanced players looking for the perfect shot and club selection.
Does this Garmin Approach S1 GPS Golf Watch have any other limitations for more advanced players or any other general flaws?
There are two important disadvantages to bear in mind with this model: its place within the range and the design of the charger. Many buyers urge others to make sure that the four pins of the charger are properly connected because it is a bit picky and can appear to be working fine and charging properly, only for users to find the watch isn’t ready when they need it.
The battery life does not help this issue issue either because the promise is for a life of “3 weeks in watch mode and 8 hours in GPS mode” and many buyers feel that get little more than two rounds worth out of it before it dies. As for the model’s place within the range, it is worth remembering Garmin’s claim of this being “golf’s first full-featured sports watch and golf GPS in one”.
This the S1, which now means it is the oldest, most basic form in a wider range, and this can be seen in the lack of information on offer compared to the S2 or S4. If you are looking for precise course data on all aspects of the hole, such as hazard locations, then you might be disappointed.
Summary: What effect do this limitations have on a recommendation for this Garmin GPS Golf Watch?
In short, this GPS system is not recommendable for the serious golfer because its flaws and the shortcomings in the functions mean it just doesn’t quite do enough. The issues with the charger and battery life mean that players looking for a full day of perfecting their game can be easily disappointed and the accuracy, while only a few yards out, can have a significant impact on the result of the game.
Instead, this Garmin S1 watch is best recommended for newer, more casual players who will not be relying on the device too much for an improved result. This watch may not have all the data of other options but it is still convenient, comfortable and helpful for basic shots to the green and can therefore still be a great aid for amateur golfers.